2014 BMW 428i
$10,000
15.4% under (target 20%)
82000
2014 BMW 428i
San Jose, CA
apify (facebook)
Nov 06 18:04
unknown / unknown
private
—
status: new
Verdict: Below market
- Asking $10,000 vs $11,827 adjusted market value from 6 comps (low confidence).
- 15% under market, short of your 20% target; negotiate down $-538 more to hit it.
- Mileage 82,000 is 26% above the comps' median 65,000, which justifies a lower price.
- Private seller: more room to negotiate, no dealer fees.
- Title status not stated; confirm it is clean before trusting the value.
- Comps disagree (spread 353.7%), so the market value is soft.
Risks
medium Title status not stated: verify before paying anything
medium Accident history unverified: no report attached
medium No VIN: cannot decode or run a history report
medium Comparables disagree (spread 353.7%)
medium Expected net $-3,873 is below your minimum $1,000
Valuation confidence: low
$11,827
$9,795
$9,011 / $10,383
6 · 353.7% · 0.0 days
10.0%/yr (default; add more listings of this model to fit a curve)
condition ×1.0, title ×0.97, accident ×0.97, hold ×0.854, ask→sale ×0.97
Basis: median of 6 adjusted asking-price comps.
Comparables are asking prices, not verified transactions. Title and accident history are unverified unless a report was attached. Market conditions can change over the hold period; this is an estimate, not a guarantee.
Comparables (asking prices, adjusted to this vehicle)
| Comp | Asking | Adjusted | Adjustments | Seen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 BMW 428i 65000 mi · private · apify · Aptos, CA |
$13,000 | $11,196 | mileage 65,000->82,000: -1,020; year 2015->2014: x0.93 | Nov 01 17:52 |
| 2014 BMW 428i Convertible CLEAN TITLE LOW MILES with FINANCING AVAILABLE & FREE WARRANTY 63000 mi · private · apify · Alameda, CA |
$16,988 | $15,848 | mileage 63,000->82,000: -1,140 | Nov 01 17:52 |
| 2014 BMW 428i convertible only 63k miles clean title with free warranty & financing 2014000 mi · private · facebook · Alameda, CA |
$15,988 | $131,908 | mileage 2,014,000->82,000: +115,920 | Nov 01 07:22 |
| 2014 BMW 428i convertible clean title low miles with financing available & free warranty 2014 mi · private · facebook · Alameda, CA |
$15,988 | $11,189 | mileage 2,014->82,000: -4,799 | Nov 01 07:22 |
| 2015 BMW 428i gran coupe xdrive awd/4wd ? mi · private · facebook · Wilsonville, OR |
$13,999 | $13,083 | year 2015->2014: x0.93 | Oct 31 07:17 |
| 2015 BMW 428i gran coupe ? mi · private · facebook · Las Vegas, NV |
$12,900 | $12,056 | year 2015->2014: x0.93 | Oct 27 07:10 |
Add comparables (CCC-style paste)
One per line: year make model | mileage | price | site | url. Example: 2019 Toyota Tacoma | 68,000 | $26,900 | Cars.com dealer | https://...
Net outcome
| Conservative | Expected | Optimistic | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resale | $9,011 | $9,795 | $10,383 |
| Net profit / loss | $-4,657 | $-3,873 | $-3,285 |
| Return on cash | -34.5% (-23.0%/yr) | -28.7% (-19.1%/yr) | -24.3% (-16.2%/yr) |
Cost lines (total $13,668, cash invested $13,518)
| purchase price | $10,000 |
| sales tax | $938 |
| registration title | $350 |
| inspection | $150 |
| immediate repairs | $1,000 |
| holding costs | $1,080 |
| financing interest | $0 |
| selling prep | $150 |
| selling fees | $0 |
Re-run with your numbers
Contact the seller
Drafts only. You approve every message. The app can send email itself; for Facebook or Craigslist you copy the approved text into the site.
History
Re-paste the same listing link when you notice a new price and it is recorded here; drops trigger alerts.
No actions yet.
Description
82K miles